Admin Restriction Issues

Hi - I am trying to restrict access to my site to a new employee “Admin2” so that they can just have access to orders and the catalog. I added a new admin account and set up a new user profile “employee” which has the permissions that I want the new employee to have. I then edited the User Groups in Admin2's profile so that “Administrator” is declined and “employee” is available. When I log in as Admin2 though, none of the restrictions I put in place seem to be active. Also, when I look at the homepage it shows 2 Root Administrators and no “employee” members. What am I doing wrong and how do I get my employee user group to change from a root administrator to an employee with the required restrictions? Thanks in advance for your help!