Promotion conditions are being ignored

Hi, I created a catalog promotion and in conditions I have “if ALL of these conditions are TRUE”:

Categories - In - categories selected.

User Groups - Not In - Wholesale.

In Bonus I have Product Price, by percentage of the original price.

When I view the site live, I see the categories NOT included in the conditions are still reflecting the discounted price. I even tried it the other way - doing categories NOT in, and selecting the categories I don't want the sale in, and the sale still shows up regardless what I have set in the conditions of the promotion.