Prices not showing up when using options

So we carry multiple sizes of bottles for a lot of our product and we use options to set a drop down price picker. The first product in a category will show the price but the rest wont. If you sort them differently it will still be the first product price that shows up is priced and the rest wont be. If you go up a category the first product from each sub category will show prices.


Any idea how to fix this? Tried seaching to no avail.